- Reply
- Signatures
- My Posts
- Jump to page: 1, 2, 3
- Next Page ›
- Last Page »
Suspects
Evan Tolliver
Sinead Starling
Ian Kabra
Hamilton Holt
Jake Rosenbloom
Jonah Wizard
Un-be-li-ev-a-ble. I can't imagine any of them being V3. But one shall be. Post your thoughts here and discussions HERE! My money's on Evan :P
I am an Alter Ego. Ashley and Fyre came up with this idea. They forced me to write this, threataning to throw me in the Ditch.
Posted at: 10:13 am on July 18, 2012
I think it's Evan or Jake. The others have been through too much to be a mole. INCLUDING IAN.
I think it's Evan. He put that picture on 'Message Board', and, well, he's in the perfect position to be a mole.
-Kade
Not all who wander are lost…
Posted at: 11:13 am on July 18, 2012
It's Evan. Definite. The others have been through too much. INCLUDING IAN.
Evan's in the perfect position to be a mole.
Sorry if I posted something like this before.
-Kade
Not all who wander are lost…
Posted at: 11:15 am on July 18, 2012
Dude, you rock! Okay. I can't believe this!
Facts:
Jonah: It is possible, but since he was in the Clue Hunt, probably not. Jonah: X
Sinead: Clearly, no. Sinead: X
Ian: NOPE! Not a chance. Ian: X
Hamilton: X
Jake: He just, isn't the person. His father wants him to go home and....why would they kidnap his brother?
Evan: He always has....seemed to get his way in....unfortunetly......It is him. It all adds up. It's him. No questions asked. I always wanted Amy to be happy.....oh well. :( Oh well Roland.
Naomi A LUCIAN that wants to be voted for! :D
Proud Christian
Some people need to be high -fived. In the face. With a chair. Made of steel.
Posted at: 11:50 am on July 18, 2012
I'm thinking it may be Evan...
The authors are trying to make you think its Ian. But this series runs on stuff thats unexpected.... Thats a little too obvious for me.
"I would've thought you would have given me the benefit of the doubt," "After all, we do have a considerable history together." -Ian, TNO
Posted at: 11:55 am on July 18, 2012
Evan Tolliver: Well, I never trusted the guy in the first place. And we dont know much about his background, either.
Sinead Starling: I honestly dont think that Sinead is it. I mean, Ted was kidnapped! And Ted was her brother!
Ian Kabra: I really dont think so. I mean, Natalie was kidnapped! And Ian really likes Amy to much. I really cant explain this, but I dont think he's V3.
Hamilton Holt: He helped Amy and Dan with a lot of stuff! And Reagan is a hostage! Hamilton probably isnt it.
Jake Rosenbloom: He's a total bonehead, but he probably isnt a Vesper because Atticus was kidnapped.
Jonah Wizard: I honestly dont know, but I dont think so.
My most likely suspect is Evan. No offense, anyone its just that he's a very likely canidate.
-Vivian
"Now I'm shooting you in high definition!" -Reagan Holt
Thank you for noticing I am awesome
Daughter of Apollo
They say life is a battlefield...I say bring it on
Posted at: 12:04 pm on July 18, 2012
I am an Alter Ego. Ashley and Fyre came up with this idea. They forced me to write this, threataning to throw me in the Ditch.
Posted at: 12:13 pm on July 18, 2012
If anyone wants the first chapters of Shatterproof, go to: http://cdn.static.the39clues.com/pdf/excerpts/39CV204_Shatterproof.pdf
I am an Alter Ego. Ashley and Fyre came up with this idea. They forced me to write this, threataning to throw me in the Ditch.
Posted at: 12:19 pm on July 18, 2012
1. Evan Tolliver : Non-Cahill
2. Sinead Starling : Name on spy camera card (possible hint)
3. Ian Kabra : Left with no warning
4. Hamilton Holt : traveling gives a chance to report and do missions
5. Jake Rosenbloom : Same as Evan6. Jonah Wizard : Same as Hamilton
My money is also on Evan but I'm ready to expect the unexpected.
Johnathan Cahill aka smart guy
Ekaterina
Book reader extrordinaire
My friends call me "Supernerd"
Posted at: 12:41 pm on July 18, 2012
Proud Catholic!
Posted at: 1:20 pm on July 18, 2012
I am an Alter Ego. Ashley and Fyre came up with this idea. They forced me to write this, threataning to throw me in the Ditch.
Posted at: 1:58 pm on July 18, 2012
Evan Tolliver
9.4
Sinead Starling
3.2
Ian Kabra
4.4
Hamilton Holt
2.9
Jake Rosenbloom
6.8
Jonah Wizard
2.9
My opinion.
I am an Alter Ego. Ashley and Fyre came up with this idea. They forced me to write this, threataning to throw me in the Ditch.
Posted at: 2:34 pm on July 18, 2012
Sherlock: And I die in disgrace.
Moriarty: Of course. That is the whole point of this.
Sherlock TV Series: The Reichenbach Fall
Posted at: 4:32 pm on July 18, 2012
1. His dad was a suspect and told about it in card pck 4.
2. Picture of Jonah on stage and perfectly behind him is the Vesper symbol.
3. Antarctic Trailer has a penguin with a Vesper necklace.
4. His mom probably joined the Vespers so he would do anything for her, so he joined.
5. He doesn't go on the M.B.
6. They are just using Tolliver to make people think he's the mole.
7. They hinted in Clifford Riley's e-book that the Vespers were extremely impressed ith Jonah on the clues hunt.
8. His rock-star stuff is probably just a distraction.
9. He was obviously hoping to not talk to Sandy Bancroft s he wouldn't recognize him as a Vesper so the Cahills wouldn't find out.
10. Grace constantly sent stuff to Fiske Cahill about the Wizards as suspects.
And that's all. The only doubt I have is that in Vesper hunt, Jonah has a card. So I'm 95% sure!
The eyes are the window to the soul
Posted at: 4:39 pm on July 18, 2012
I am an Alter Ego. Ashley and Fyre came up with this idea. They forced me to write this, threataning to throw me in the Ditch.
Posted at: 5:17 pm on July 18, 2012
Bridget and Heather
TreeSap
LemonCake
Posted at: 6:00 pm on July 18, 2012
Join the Dragon Alliance! Fun for ALL!
I will not on much as of now. I am sorry.
If your lost and alone, or your sinking like a stone carry on.
Posted at: 6:55 pm on July 18, 2012
James: Lucian Luitenant
A Victory without Danger
Is a Triumph without Glory -
Pierre Corneille
Posted at: 7:54 pm on July 18, 2012
Suspects
Evan Tolliver-
Possibly. Nah, probably.He's a really shady character, and he seemed unnerved when they were figuring out Nellie's lizard. Was it because Amy kissed Jake? Or was it because the Cahills were getting so close to figuring out where the hostages were?
Sinead Starling-
A little suspicious, too. She could have been trying to get Evan to wear the tracker because she thought he was V-3, but he could be a Cahill, needing tracking by the Vespers.
Ian Kabra-
He's been a suspicious character right from the start. Look at his mother's maiden name, for starters. Isabel Vesper-Hollingsworth. Also, was he the mole since he trapped Amy in the cave in South Korea? Natalie could be a decoy hostage, monitoring activity of the other Cahills. She, after all, didn't seem that worried about being trapped. She was far more relaxed, and her complaints were trivial.
Hamilton Holt-
Hamilton's a little suspicious. Was he trying to send a secret message to V-4 in Italy, when they met him? Could he have used Dan to get information all along, since The Black Circle? Though not as suspicious as the others, he is still, after all, a suspect.
Jake Rosenbloom-
We don't know a lot about these so-called Guardians. Atticus is probably too close to Dan to possibly betray him like that. Astrid's background is unknown. Though an active Guardian and involved with the families closely, she could also be a double agent.
Jonah Wizard-
Another one. I'm pretty sure that he could be a mole. His mother probably cut off contact with him after she discovered he was a Vesper. Brodrick's a Vesper. Cora's been using Brodrick to access Vesper info, so he got mad and eventually sided with his son, at the end of the clue hunt.
Here's my scale:
Evan Tolliver
6.8
Sinead Starling
5.5
Ian Kabra
7.9
Hamilton Holt
5.2
Jake Rosenbloom
6.8
Jonah Wizard
7.8
Montego
BURNING BLU
William . Montego . Jessica
Vote BLU in the Lucian Elections at
www.the39clues.com/messageboard/show/46720
Posted at: 8:08 pm on July 18, 2012
P.S: BUMP!
Johnathan Cahill aka smart guy
Ekaterina
Book reader extrordinaire
My friends call me "Supernerd"
Posted at: 8:51 pm on July 18, 2012
This is the girl that saves the world.
Sabrina Grimm, queen of the sneaks.
Sisters Grimm: The Council of Mirrors
Posted at: 9:01 pm on July 18, 2012
Tyler
My pie! Llamanator
Posted at: 9:46 pm on July 18, 2012
-Isabel Kabra
-Bae Oh
-Casper Wyoming
-Brodrick Wizard
-Erasmus Yilmaz
-Eisenhower Holt
-Vikram Kabra
-NRR
Montego
BURNING BLU
William . Montego . Jessica
Vote BLU in the Lucian Elections at
www.the39clues.com/messageboard/show/46720
Posted at: 12:18 am on July 19, 2012
Laura
When the silent majority opens its mouth it is usually to yawn.
-Gerd de Lay
Pay It Forward = A Chain Reaction of Compassion
Posted at: 1:01 am on July 19, 2012
Sinead's not possible, because she was injured at the Franklin Institute with her brothers, and Ted was kidnapped.
Hamilton's also not it, because he didn't want his family to die in Into the Gauntlet. Maybe he had already an alliance with Isabel at that time? Or they were cooperating just to try to trick us? Other than that, He's not it.
Evan might be it, because he was in the command center as soon as he came back from school, and maybe he can contact with other Vespers during school, and he was a suspect for Vesper 5.
Jonah might be it, because Broderick Wizard is a Vesper, so maybe Broderick is using Jonah to gain information about the Cahills.
Jake also might be V3's assistant because he could be spying on Amy and Dan.
Ian has a big chance of being it because his mother was a Vesper, and did Linda Sue Park said that in Book 5 Amy and Dan were going to Brazil? And Vikram also went to Brazil? So I think that Ian is it.
Scale
Evan Tolliver: 8.6
Sinead Starling: 3.7 Ian Kabra: 9.2
Hamilton Holt: 3.5
Jake Rosenbloom: 6.4
Jonah Wizard: 7.1
I like The 39 Clues.
Phoenix 5, United Nations Hong Kong Leader blablabla...
TRUST NO ONE
Posted at: 1:30 am on July 19, 2012
I like The 39 Clues.
Phoenix 5, United Nations Hong Kong Leader blablabla...
TRUST NO ONE
Posted at: 2:56 am on July 19, 2012
Evan: For: He's a pretty new character and we don't know much about him. Also, he recognised the DeOssie smartphone. Also, in book three, he posted a picture of the unidentified lizard on the message board. Sinead scolded him for that saying a Vesper could be monitoring the board, and could alert Vesper 1. So maybe that's why Evan did it!
Against: Evan is waaaay too obvious. I think the authors know that most people suspect Evan, so they would probably choose somebody else.
Sinead: For: Also relatively new. Do we really know what she and her brothers were doing between books one and ten? Also, have you noticed that she doesn't have her own card?
Against: Her brother's a hostage. And she has a backup in the Vesper Hunt and in The Dead of Night Mission.
Ian: For: Ian was the main bad guy in the clue hunt. Can we really be sure he's reformed? And his mother's a Vesper! Also, in The Medusa Plot, when Vesper One orders the guards to shoot one of the prisoners, they are about to shoot Natalie when a voice says: 'No.Not that one.'
Against: His sister's a hostage. Also, he has a backup in the Vesper Hunt and The Medusa Plot and A Kings Ransom Missions.
Hamilton: For: Umm... I'll have to think about him.
Against: His sister's a hostage. Plus, he has a backup on the Vesper Hunt. In A Kings Ransom, Cheyenne ties to sabotage their car so he and Jonah almost drive off a cliff. I don't think V6 would try to do that to V3.
Jake: For: He's a relatively new character, so we don't know much about him.
Against: His brother and mother are Guardians. He tries to stop Amy and dan stealing the De Virga map. In The Dead of Night the Vesper knock him unconscious and dump him in a cemetery. Would the Vespers do that to one of their own? Also, when he comes up against the Wyomings, he's shown real determination to fight them. I don't think he could fake that. And he's shown real love for his brother.
Jonah: For: His father's a Vesper. But apart from that, nothing I can think of.
Against: Same as Hamilton except it's his cousin who's a hostage not his sister.
P.S. BreakingHurricane5, where did you see the Vesper symbol?
Son of Athena
Host of Thoth
Ravenclaw
Ekat genius
The night has a thousand eyes...
Posted at: 9:20 am on July 19, 2012
1. In TDON, Evan seemed reluctant to wear the tracking bracelet, as we all know, but from the way he talked and acted, it seemed as if he has something to hide. Storming out of the room? Maybe he thought Sinead might stick a tracking device to him if he stayed, so he wouldn't want to take any risk. The way he chose his words and talked also seemed very peculiar . . .
2. In TMP, when Ian went to get the supplies, it seemed as if though he knew what Ian wanted. Why did he glance down to what Ian was holding - the paper - when any proffesional clerk knows to keep their eyes on who, and what they want. It was probably just a cover, because he didn't act very proffesional. How did he happen to be on his shift when Ian came, out of all the possibilities?
IT'S HIM!
I am an Alter Ego. Ashley and Fyre came up with this idea. They forced me to write this, threataning to throw me in the Ditch.
Posted at: 9:34 am on July 19, 2012
1. His dad was a suspect and told about it in card pack 4. That is the suspected thing, but we're not 100% sure. It could be taht he was a Guardian. BW does not seem or act like any type of Vesper.
2. Picture of Jonah on stage and perfectly behind him is the Vesper symbol. I don't see it....
3. Antarctic Trailer has a penguin with a Vesper necklace. I know which penguin you mean. It's not a "V", it's a script written "J" for 'Jonah'.
4. His mom probably joined the Vespers so he would do anything for her, so he joined. Doubt it, but there always is the possibility.
5. He doesn't go on the MB. True...imagine he just posts today XD
6. They are just using Tolliver to make people think he's the mole. They could use the Tolliver-cover-up for any suspect, so that doesn't make it 100% that they used it for Jonah.
7. They hinted in Clifford Riley's e-book that the Vespers were extremely impressed with Jonah on the clues hunt. I didn't get the book, so....
8. His rock-star stuff is probably just a distraction. Don't think so....
9. He was obviously hoping to not talk to Sandy Bancroft s he wouldn't recognize him as a Vesper so the Cahills wouldn't find out. If he was V3, Sandy bancroft would know not to talk to him,
10. Grace constantly sent stuff to Fiske Cahill about the Wizards as suspects. Cora, probably.
-Kade
Not all who wander are lost…
Posted at: 9:58 am on July 19, 2012
'"I like trains too, boss!" Waste of Time added eagerly.
~RedPuppy47, The Egypt RP
Posted at: 10:01 am on July 19, 2012
Mary
FAITH, TRUST, PIXIE DUST AND A HARNESS TO LIFT YOU INTO THE AIR.
Posted at: 10:33 am on July 19, 2012
Parting tis' such a sweet sorrow,
but nothing lasts forever.
I am gone,
but shall return
~Destiney(who has been reading tooooo many old books)
Posted at: 11:18 am on July 19, 2012
I am an Alter Ego. Ashley and Fyre came up with this idea. They forced me to write this, threataning to throw me in the Ditch.
Posted at: 1:00 pm on July 19, 2012
the rest are Cahils ecsept Jake who i trust.
HANNAH
What is Right is not always Popular and what Popular is Not always Right.
I can do anything through Him who gives me strength.
Pill. 4:13
,
Posted at: 1:35 pm on July 19, 2012
its has to be Evan!
i mean, idk where i got this, but somewhere i read that evan was talking to a vesper which was his
uncle or something.
long lost uncle....
im pretty sure it was in one of the books :O
plus, for hamilton, jonah, ian, sinead, and jake, somebody in their family was kidnapped.
somebody they were close too.
Evan is non-cahill, and doesnt have anybody he is close too that was kidnapped.
i'm so sorry too all of u girls that like him

its gotta be him
if it isnt him, then u may insult me all u want ;)
Melle
i am a madrigal now, always was, and always will be!
let the hostages be safe!
I am here to help, i am here to advise, and i am here to sacrifice.
so reach out.
Posted at: 1:50 pm on July 19, 2012
EVAN-i never trusted him cuz well....non cahill...way too smart...even then an ekat...so yeah
SINEAH-i cant really imagine her as bertaying us considering Y WOULD SHE LET HER GROUP STEAL HER BROTHER.....then again it could be used as a coverup,but y would she work so hard to find the hostage location if she already knows it??......she doesnt seem like an actor
IAN-strong suspion that he is.....but i think my mind DOESNT want it to be him......he has too much history and he did seprate from his mother...the vesper
HAMMER- after all he did in the clue hunt by going aganist his father and living up to his thoughts of life....then i dont think so....unless he changed that....he doesnt seem like a liar since he went aganist doing it at the clue hunt and he cant kill anyone
JAKE-it can be him since we dont really know anything about him but.........he wouldnt let anyone harm his brother even his oranization(if he was a vesper)
JONAH-his father is a vesper and he is good at acting.....but y would he betray us??????????he really doesnt have much resaon too...unless...something made him turn evil
@BronzePuppy5....do u buy the books cuz i needed to do the mission to figure out it the other vespers......
I REALLY DONT WANT TO FIGURE OUT WHO IT IS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! I DONT WANT TO SEE WHO BETRAY US!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!......and who dies
“What you see before you, my friend, is the result of a lifetime of chocolate.”
Posted at: 1:58 pm on July 19, 2012
Sinead: Ted
Ian: Natelie
Hamilton: Regan
Jake: Atticus.
Jonah: His cousin (I don't remember his name)
Aqua Loin
Rob
Tomas Assasin
Leader of the NAT
Posted at: 3:11 pm on July 19, 2012
Callie
Light travels faster than sound. That is why some people appear bright until you hear them speak.
Posted at: 3:22 pm on July 19, 2012